Colorado Judge Keeps Trump on Ballot, Rejecting 14th Amendment Argument

Please log in or register to do it.

A Colorado judge ruled on Friday that former President Donald J. Trump could remain on the ballot in the state, rejecting the argument that the 14th Amendment prevents him from holding office again.

It was the first time a court had ruled on the merits of whether Mr. Trump, with his actions before and during the Jan. 6, 2021, attack on the U.S. Capitol, had engaged in insurrection against the Constitution after taking an oath to support it — an offense deemed disqualifying by Section 3 of the 14th Amendment, which was ratified in 1868 to keep former Confederates out of the government.

The twist was that Sarah B. Wallace, the Denver district court judge overseeing the case, ruled that Mr. Trump did engage in insurrection — but that Section 3 did not apply to him.

Because the clause does not explicitly name the presidency, the question hinged on whether the president was included in the category “officer of the United States.”

Because of “the absence of the president from the list of positions to which the amendment applies combined with the fact that Section Three specifies that the disqualifying oath is one to ‘support’ the Constitution whereas the presidential oath is to ‘preserve, protect and defend’ the Constitution,” Judge Wallace wrote, “it appears to the court that for whatever reason the drafters of Section Three did not intend to include a person who had only taken the presidential oath.”

Similar lawsuits in Minnesota and New Hampshire were dismissed on procedural grounds, and a judge in Michigan ruled that the questions were political ones that courts did not have the authority to decide.

The plaintiffs in Colorado — four Republicans and two independent voters who sued in September — are expected to appeal, and the United States Supreme Court will almost certainly have the final say. Cases are also underway in other states.

The decision by Judge Wallace followed a weeklong trial in which lawyers for the plaintiffs laid out the case for disqualification in detail.

They called eight witnesses, including two police officers who responded to the Jan. 6 attack; a Democratic congressman who was in the Capitol during it; and the chief investigative counsel for the House’s Jan. 6 investigative committee, whose report the plaintiffs cited extensively. But the centerpiece of their case was the testimony of two professors.

Peter Simi, an expert on political extremism, testified that far-right groups routinely relied on implicit, plausibly deniable calls for violence, and that Mr. Trump had communicated with them in that way — an argument presented to rebut the defense that he never explicitly told anyone to storm the Capitol. And Gerard Magliocca, an expert on Section 3 of the 14th Amendment, testified that at the time it was ratified, “engaging in insurrection” had been understood to include verbal incitement of force to prevent the execution of the law.

Mr. Trump’s lawyers called one expert, Robert Delahunty, a law professor who testified that Section 3 was vague and that it should be up to Congress to define it. Their other witnesses included a former Defense Department official who said Mr. Trump had pre-emptively authorized the use of National Guard troops to prevent violence on Jan. 6 — followed by people who were at Mr. Trump’s rally on the Ellipse that day, who testified that they had not heard his words as a call to violence and that the crowd had been peaceful before part of it turned violent.

Judge Wallace’s inquiries during the trial betrayed little of her thinking. When she rejected a request from Mr. Trump’s team to throw out the case before the trial was complete, she emphasized that the legal and constitutional questions it posed were novel and difficult.

Related Posts
In Israel, Christie Says Trump Ducked Mideast Progress and Fueled Bigotry

Chris Christie, the former governor of New Jersey who is challenging Donald J. Trump for the Republican presidential nomination, said Read more

Trump attorney sounds alarm on NY AG Letitia James amid civil fraud case: ‘She campaigned on Trump’

Trump attorney Alina Habba joined "Sunday Morning Futures" with host Maria Bartiromo on Sunday to discuss the latest on the Read more

Donald Trump’s older sister Maryanne Trump Barry dead at 86, NYPD confirms

Maryanne Trump Barry, the older sister of former President Donald Trump, has died Monday at the age of 86, the Read more

Trump’s Older Sister, Maryanne Trump Barry, Dies at 86
Trump’s Older Sister, Maryanne Trump Barry, Dies at 86

A retired federal judge in New Jersey, she supported her brother but, as secret audio recordings revealed in 2019, she Read more

A Journey Into Northern Gaza: Ruins, Wreckage and Darkness
North Carolina mayoral race decided by coin toss

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *